Category Archives: Culture

Visions of Manhood

What makes for a good life?

I saw what sounds like the modern American Dream written up in the Wall Street Journal yesterday.

The story was about a man. Just your everyday TikTok superstar. He was once an executive at one of the most powerful companies in the world. Then his wife hit social media superstardom, and he left his job to seek his fortune through fame as well. And it worked. Together they became a social media powerhouse. Followers in the millions. They traveled the world sharing self-help wisdom, using their lives as the fodder for their business. They wrote bestsellers and spent most of their days taking pictures and videos glamorizing their personal lives as a model for the rest of us to follow.

That seems like the modern day success story we are all supposed to follow.

His is the kind of story that makes the rest of us, whose lives are characterized by simple houses, once-a-year vacations, and a lot of homework, believe we have somehow missed the secret to life.

But the last quarter of that article chronicles what we should all know to be true by now – that the modern-day social media-fueled, perfectly sculpted, happy-life vision of manhood is less of a vision than a mirage.

The modern-day vision of the good life modeled by our social media superstars is a fantasy created and crafted by people desperately chasing worth and meaning in all the wrong places, and those pursuing it will inevitably die of thirst and exhaustion long before the mirage ever becomes real.

Nonetheless, those fantasies still manage to shape the expectations and frame the disappointments many men live with their entire lives. We need better guides than men pushing their fictionalized lives as products for the rest of us to consume.

Immediately after reading the article linked above, which ends after a long road of creeping loneliness, hidden loss, divorce, and eventual death, I saw a video posted on X of a man who models the exact opposite of the American Dream masculine mirage.

This man, working a job that requires a lot of hours wearing a safety vest, models a different vision of manhood than our culture puts before you.

He lives a life of sacrifice for those who love him. And those who love him keep him living. His story will not end in creeping loneliness. It will deepen and broaden as his family grows. His life will not be marked by growing influence in empty digital landscapes. It will be marked by the people he loves who love him in return.

How do we shift our focus away from the mirage of the good life marked by personal success, self-fulfillment, and dumb-money living?

How do we re-enchant the vision of a simple, joy-filled, love-soaked life? How do we teach men to embrace a life of self-sacrifice as a means to lasting joy?

Rethinking Church in 2024

The year is 1002 BC, one king has died and a new king has been annointed. If you could have stood on the high, strong walls of the ancient city of Hebron, you would have looked down on a kingdom perched on the knife’s edge of failure and opportunity.

The former king, Saul, after losing a battle with his sworn enemies, the Philistines, heroically upheld his honor, choosing to fall on his own sword rather than suffer humiliation and suffering at his enemy’s hands. The new king, David, is gathering his armies, and choosing his path for the future. 

Standing in the walls of Hebron in these days would have put you in the epicenter of a catalytic moment. 

Armies are gathering from all the tribes of Israel. Thousands upon thousands of troops. Each tribe bringing a unique, specific skill set, shaped by their environment, honed by experience, and offered in support of the kingdom. 

Judah brought shields and swordsmen. (1 Chronicles 12:24 The men of Judah bearing shield and spear were 6,800 armed troops)

The Simeonites were war-hardened men accustomed to the pains of battle. (1 Chronicles 12:25 Of the Simeonites, mighty men of valor for war, 7,100)

The Levites, men of the temple, showed up with great intentions. (1 Chronicles 12:26 Of the Levites 4,600)

All the tribes, gathering their thousands under the leadership of David, would pass through the gates of Hebron, offering their skill set to aid the king as he leads them into an uncertain future. 

But one tribe stands out. One small tribe coming through the gate, making their way through the masses of warriors and mighty armies, would be an oddity among the troops, peculiar both for the size of their contingent and the skill set they offer to the kingdom.

They are the men of Issachar. A group of 200 in the company of thousands upon thousands. And what they bring in the midst of looming battle and roiling insecurity was not another instrument of war. They bring wisdom. 

These were the men “who knew the signs of the times and knew what Israel should do.”

They brought perception to see what thousands of warriors missed.  

They brought wisdom to guide armies and discover best strategies. 

They were the people who could tackle the most tangled problems and answer the most difficult questions, and they showed up in Hebron to offer their skill set for the good of the kingdom. 

I see that moment in 1 Chronicles 12 as a helpful metaphor to consider right now, because I think I live in a church culture that has been defeated in battle.

To be very clear, what I am saying is that American Christendom has fallen.

I am not an alarmist. I do not think the Kingdom of God is threatened by anything. Full stop. I do not write this out of fear. And it should not be received with fear. At all. 

Fear is the tool of the Enemy. 

“Do not fear” is the clarion call of our Kingdom.

If you feel the Kingdom of God is threatened by anything in our culture you need to enlarge your trust in our King. 

The Kingdom of God is never under threat. But our little kingdom of American Christendom, if not dead already, is surrounded by its loved ones receiving its last rites. 

We are in a post-Christian culture. Dr. Stuart Murray-Williams defines post-Christendom in this way:

‘Post-Christendom is the culture that emerges as the Christian faith loses coherence within a society that has been definitively shaped by the Christian story and as the institutions that have been developed to express Christian convictions decline in influence.’

Christianity has lost coherence with the values of our society. Christian institutions have been declining for fifty years. Our assumed control and influence have waned, and our institutions of authority are falling. 

We are the kingdom of Israel after losing the battle to the Philistines. 

The question confronting us now is which king will we choose to be? 

Will we heroically fall on our swords, desperately trying to preserve our honor and demonstrate our fidelity in the face of defeat? 

Or will gather together the resources available to us, seek the signs of our times, and let wisdom guide our future steps?

I want to follow David’s lead. I am trying to identify the men of Issachar who will help me know what we, the people of God in the American church should do, and this series of Rethinking Church will help me do exactly that.

A Modern Issacharian Worth Your Time: Brad Briscoe and his book, Rethink. Get it for free at New Churches.

Resources on Race Relations

racial reconciliationFor the last year, I have been wading into the swampy mess of American race relations. Like all good swamps, the water is murky, every step you take comes with danger of being attacked, and visibility is limited. But I’m still moving through it.

Now, I invite you to join me, white friends. Come on in, the water’s fine.

Continue reading

Patriots and Exiles: Why #NeverTrump?

NeverTrump.pngIt seems that Trump has won the republican nomination. I know the game is not over yet. But after taking Florida as one of his 18 wins, he is no longer an unruly house guest overstaying his welcome, he now has more right to the space than anyone else in the room. He is flat-out winning, and no appeal to a divided voting block changes the simple fact of his clear and consistent march to victory. He keeps winning, which puts many people I know, love, and respect into the awkward position of voting for a man they detest in order to uphold the conservative principles of the party they love.

I don’t feel a hint of that awkwardness, though, because I can firmly, without hesitation, say I will never vote for a man like Trump. And I want to tell you why.

Continue reading

Conviction

I just finished a little facebook tussle, which is second on my list of ultimately futile activities, over status update I made about a hot button cultural issue, which is the straightest line leading to the second most futile activity known to man. In this little back and forth, it became very clear that I was wielding a sword in what the other person assumed was a pool noodle fight. In that scenario, neither person looks too bright.

But this kerfuffle brought a number of thoughts to mind as I reflected. The whole situation was interesting to me on a number of levels:

1. Should we speak? People love to speak, but rarely have something to say. Social media has given us the ability to speak, which has morphed into an obligation to speak. This cuts towards me just as much as it does to the other person involved. I deleted about eight different tweets about the topic I brought up, because it was far too big a topic for a tweet. So why did I keep writing them until I clicked Tweet? Because I felt compelled to speak, primarily because I was able to speak. For the person who responded to me, there was a compulsion to say something in response to my saying something, but a vague and indefinite fortune cookie maxim was all they had available at the moment. But if I was speaking to something much larger than I could reasonably address, and if the person responding had nothing of substance to say in response, perhaps we should both have just stopped typing.

2. Speak with conviction. The person’s initial response was vague, and the follow up responses were a mix of denying what they had vaguely said, backing out of the argument they started, and at one point saying they had no intention at all behind what they said. If there is no intention, why say anything? And the answer is simple – there was intention behind responding to my status update, but the intention lacked the fortification of conviction. Paraphrasing Stinger, The person’s rebuttals were writing checks his conviction couldn’t cash.

3. Taylor Mali knows what I’m talking about.

4. Humility should be attached to ambition, not knowledge. G.K.Chesterton, writing about a hundred years ago noted this new tendency for people to act as though pretending not to know something was humble. That is relativism, agnosticism, or laziness, but it is not humility. Humility is meant to limit our inner world, not write off the outer one.

5. Christians must speak with conviction. Have you ever had that moment when a group of friends are trying to decide where to go eat, and all of them, looking out for the happiness of the others, keep deferring to everyone else, who are all deferring to everyone else? All it takes is one person with the conviction of personal desire, and the Mexican standoff will end. Our culture is at one massive Mexican standoff, and we desperately need Christians to step in and bring the clarity, honesty, and peace that can only come through Christian conviction.

In summary: don’t speak unless you have both something to say and the conviction to bring others with you.

Manhood Issues: Countering Apathy

lazy menLast week, I moved. I am sincerely grateful that small portion of my life is over. I am convinced that Hell physically manifests itself in the form of boxes, trucks, furniture, narrow doorways and stairs. And it’s hot.

One day last week, in order to take a break from moving, I took my car to get the oil changed. I know, I am writing a post about declining manhood and I don’t even change my own oil. Pathetic, I know. But give me a minute here. I took my car to get the oil changed, and I noticed something really interesting. As I watched three different couples deal with mechanics, explain car problems, fill out papers, and pay there was a consistent pattern of movement displayed by each of the three couples I saw. The men stood slightly behind the women and spoke only when spoken to.

It was fascinating to watch once I picked up on this pattern. Women would approach the counter first. Women would talk with the mechanic. Women would lead the way to the waiting area. Women would step up to pay. Men followed behind like children, waiting for mom to make the next decision.

Now, let me throw out a few qualifiers to explain my reason for surprise and the noteworthiness of this pattern.

  1. Car stuff is not man stuff. I do not think women to be unfit or incapable of handling car issues. I do not consider it unmanly to be unfamiliar with cars. That is not the source of my surprise.
  2. Standing behind is not a sign of weakness, lower status, or lessened capability. There are many areas in our life where my wife takes the lead for me, and I stay out of the way. I do not find that to be a mark against me as a man.
  3. There is nothing wrong with strong willed, independent women that can take care of business. On the contrary, I think an industrious, capable spirit is one of the most attractive qualities a woman can display. Solomon thought so as well, seeing that Proverbs 31 devotes more time to the hard work of a woman than any other attribute.

Those qualifiers out of the way, the pattern of movement displayed by the people in my local garage displayed something attested to in study after of study of the modern man: men are disengaged.

Please understand the limit to what I am saying: I do not define masculinity and femininity by particular tasks or tastes. Masculinity and femininity are best defined by attitudes and dispositions of the heart. This post is not about defining masculinity, but I will happily point you towards a few that are: here, here, and here.

So finally, after dancing with the lions of outraged feminism, the problem I want to address is one of creating some proactive momentum. When I started cleaning out my home office for the move last week, I sat in my chair and surveyed the state of my stuff for about 30 minutes before I moved a muscle. Why? Because I had no clue where to begin making sense of my own mess. I want to provide some insight for men who similarly look at their own passivity and have no idea where to start making changes.

  1. Admit you have a problem, and then admit the problem is bigger than you just admitted. Tell you roommate. Tell your spouse. Tell your parents. Tell someone in your life that you want to make a change. The reason is simple; you have likely grown numb to letting yourself down, so bring someone else’s expectations into the equation to provide some accountability.
  2. Give yourself some goals. Make goals according to two criteria: Small and SMART. Make your goals small, because the goal here is to create some proactive momentum, not conquer the world. Also, make sure they are SMART goals. Specific. Measurable. Achievable. Relevant. Time-sensitive. Read this – and start making plans!
  3. If you are married and struggle with passivity, then you need to follow John Piper’s advice and bring two little words into your vocabulary that will revolutionize your relationship: “Let us”. Train yourself to be the first one in the house to say “Let’s” you will have become the de facto initiator and leader of your household. Be the one thinking ahead for your household’s needs, and be the one who addresses them first. “Honey, let’s…” Those two little words can change everything.

So, if you struggle with passivity, try making those 3 little changes in your daily life. Most importantly though, recognize that unhealthy passivity is a result of brokenness in your heart. You can try to change your actions, but the most important factor in lasting change comes when you allow God to change your heart. Phenom rapper, Lecrae, has an excellent message and testimony about how God challenges and changes your understanding of manhood. Well worth your 42 minutes.

 

 

Is Christianity Exclusive? Yes and no.

midcentury-modern-doorsOne of the most common critiques of Christianity in Western culture comes from an accusation of its inherent exclusivity. The cultural, social, and political elites of our age have judged the values of our time, and have thus decided to exclude exclusion from polite society. As such, a religion marked by one way, one truth and one light fails to open enough doors to include everyone. This anti-exclusive dogma is the most dangerous type of nonsense imaginable – nonsense turned common sense.

Therefore, I would like to explore two functional definitions of exclusivity followed by a response to the charge of Christian exclusivity as evil. Hopefully, what is common sense will be displayed as nonsense.

Continue reading

A Deadly Need in the Church

imagesThis post has a pretty limited audience. I am writing to pastors. I am calling you to work through some tough issues for the sake of the Millennials in your church. In case you do not know, Millennials are the young adults born between 1980 and 2000. Here are a few articles for those interested in learning about our habits in the workplace, our good points, our bad points, and our beliefs. We are an 80 million strong nightmare for most authority figures from the Baby Boomer Generation.

Those authority figures include pastors.

Continue reading

Polygamy – The Next Marriage Frontier

downloadI watched a debate not long ago between a conservative pastor and a gay marriage activist in which the pastor was roundly dismissed for suggesting that the normalization of gay marriage inevitably leads to the normalization of any type of “marriage.” That prediction is coming true already. Watch this video of a polygamist family who will star in their own reality television show. The argument put forth by the wife in the white sweater for the normalcy of their lifestyle is the exact argument put forth by proponents of gay marriage.

The marriage wars have only just begun.

 

 

Be More Judgmental. -The Apostle Paul

2Earlier today I read an article from Christianity Today about Donald Miller’s recent declarations about his relationship with Church gatherings, confusingly called church. I do not think he is forsaking the universal Church, because that would mean forsaking Jesus. I think he is forsaking the Church gatherings which have come to be known as church. That is how I read what Miller says here and here.

I agree with Kevin Miller’s assessment of Brian Maclaren and Rob Bell. I think he prematurely loops Donald Miller in with them unless he argues from the perspective of trajectory, which I would think a very fitting argument. Either way, Kevin Miller is experiencing the same push back any Christian feels when they call out another Christian’s actions or words as dangerous, lacking in wisdom, or out of step with the Bible. You hear the accusation coming from believers and unbelievers alike. It comes with both patronizing disdain and vicarious offense. It comes down in one word. Judgmental.

Continue reading

Living Stone Community Church

All of Christ. For all of life.

Denny Burk

A commentary on theology, politics, and culture

The Gospel Coalition

Tid-bits and Trifles on Faith, Culture, and Church from Whitney Clayton

The Gospel Coalition

Tid-bits and Trifles on Faith, Culture, and Church from Whitney Clayton

The Gospel Coalition

Tid-bits and Trifles on Faith, Culture, and Church from Whitney Clayton

Design a site like this with WordPress.com
Get started